“My cup runneth over – but who's paying for the coffee?”


The biggest hassle in my 50 years of ministry? Stingy Christians. Which is strange if you think about it – which I am about to do in this blog!
Strangely, even as a young child I recall my mother telling me that church people were tight. There's clearly some history behind that comment, some of which I am aware of.
This impression was reinforced when, as a teenager, I was invited to a barbecue organised by Christian Youth Rallies, in the days when the Brethren assemblies on Merseyside were a force to be reckoned with. I don't remember the exact words of a satirical song sung from the stage, but basically it poked fun at how church members would arrive in their Jaguars to worship in a tin hut!
So, right at the outset of my ministry, I knew what I was signing up for, even as I made arrangements for my first curacy. I was expected to come cheap. And for the record, I must pay tribute, albeit somewhat reluctantly, to my various dioceses, who over the years have protected me from stingy Christians.
I recall being interviewed to be vicar of a church in an affluent suburb and being shown the vicarage by the churchwardens. They apologised for the condition of the kitchen but added reassuringly, "Don't worry! A church member has just installed a brand-new (and no doubt very expensive) kitchen and has very kindly donated the old one to the vicarage!"
I should have burst into song along with Barbra Streisand:
Everyone knows that I'm just (Second Hand Rose)
(The Second-hand) not quite! Let's see if you know the fills
Once while strolling through the Ritz, a girl got my goat
She nudged her friend and said, "Oh, look, there goes my old fur coat!"
(You don't need me!)
However, the main battlefield over the years has been coffee.
In Rochdale, we decided to introduce coffee after our main church service – a move that felt revolutionary at the time, long before widespread ecological awareness. To overcome the practical difficulties of serving everyone, we used disposable, pre-filled cups which simply required hot water straight from the kettle.
It seemed a great idea – except to Pat, who led the opposition. She was mildly furious at the waste. "They can drink their coffee at home!"
Which leads me directly to True Confession Time.
I'm not sure who organised the coffee rota at Christ Church, but for drinks after the main service they chose to use Tesco's white-label brand, just about the cheapest coffee you could buy. It tasted terrible.
So, in the dark of night, I would sneak into church unobserved and replace it with Kenco or M&S coffee, at my own expense, of course. After all, our guests deserved the best.
Which brings me to the greatest battle of all – the Battle of the Coffee Machine.
We had just opened the Ministry Centre with the goal of making Christ Church a destination in its own right throughout the week. This meant having a quality coffee shop, and we had just the right people in the congregation to run it.
A married couple had experience of running a successful coffee shop in Ormskirk – in the days when such establishments were few and far between. So I was delighted when they volunteered to run our church coffee shop.
The husband explained that it was essential to serve great coffee, but our volunteers would struggle with a commercial espresso machine. So he researched the various push-button machines and settled on one from Rijo42. This would cost £28 per week for five years, including free servicing, after which the machine would belong to the church.
So we signed up and opened Café Vista.
However, some church members strongly disagreed – and I choose my words carefully. "£28 a week, 52 weeks a year, even when the café is closed! All you need is a teaspoon and a coffee jar!"
We had just opened a £1.3 million Ministry Centre, funded almost entirely through the sacrificial giving of church members. No doubt some of those who complained had themselves contributed generously. But such is human nature: even the smallest things can sometimes assume enormous importance.
As it happened, the Rijo42 paid for itself within two years, becoming an important source of income as Café Vista took off.
The American pastor and writer Tim Keller puts his finger on the problem:
"While you can be financially generous without being generous in heart, you can't possibly be generous in heart without being shockingly generous with your money."
That's quite a challenge. For the problem with stinginess is not so much what we do with our money, but what our money does to us. And for Christians, of all people, that is particularly troubling.
After all, we sing in Psalm 23: "You anoint my head with oil; my cup overflows" (v5). Or, as the Authorised Version memorably puts it, "My cup runneth over." Runneth over – what a waste!
Certainly Jesus went over the top at Cana, producing nearly 700 litres of wine. And not just any wine, but the very best! Clearly, Jesus doesn't believe in doing things by halves.
So Jesus challenges us to be generous, over-the-top even, in our giving, just like him. "Give, and it will be given to you. A good measure, pressed down, shaken together and running over, will be poured into your lap. For with the measure you use, it will be measured to you" (Luke 6:38).
And there's the challenge. Of course, we need to be responsible with our money, especially when it has been entrusted to us by others. But there's a world of difference between being careful and being stingy.
The God we worship is extravagantly generous, whose grace overflows and whose love knows no bounds. Even if meant the most generous act in the entire cosmos – the gift of Christ crucified. Think John 3:16.



Comments